People love the fall color of oaks and maples, but one Southern native is often overlooked for its bold autumn display: the mighty bald cypress.
Native to swamps and low-lying areas, the bald cypress is both coniferous and deciduous, and is one of the more underrated trees of the Southeastern United States.
Bald cypress is incredibly tough, tolerating both drought and flooding, and it’s a perfect tree for harsh urban environments. In fact, you’ll find it thriving in cities far removed from its native range, including Philly and New York.
In late fall, the needles of the bald cypress change from green to deep orange—a spectacular sight on the landscape.
Hartshorne Plunkard Architecture with DLR Group. T3 West Midtown (2019). Atlantic Station, Atlanta.1234Balconies on the southeast corner of T3 West Midtown, AtlantaThe Foundry Park and east elevation of T3 West Midtown, AtlantaWindows on the southwest corner of T3 West Midtown, AtlantaLooking at the east elevation of T3 West Midtown, AtlantaSouth elevation of T3 West Midtown, Atlanta
James A. Wetmore with Murphy & Olmsted. United States Post Office and Courthouse (1933). Greensboro, North Carolina.12345Facade of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaLooking at the fourth floor and attic of the United States Post Office and Courthouse from the southeastThird- and fourth-floor windows and pilasters on the facade of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaOpen stone grilles and fourth-floor windows on the facade of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaBas-relief inscription above the main entrance of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaBas-relief ornamentation on the parapet of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaBas-relief fretwork and limestone block on the facade of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaOpen stone grille on the facade of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaOpen stone grille and plinth with lanterns on the facade of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaLooking at the west elevation of the United States Post Office and Courthouse from the southwestFourth-floor windows and pilasters on the west elevation of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaWindows, pilasters, and pediment above the west entrance of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North CarolinaPolished granite base and cornerstone of the United States Post Office and Courthouse, Greensboro, North Carolina
References
“Plans For New Federal Building Announced”. Greensboro Daily News (Greensboro, North Carolina), May 21, 1930, p. 1. ↩︎
Dickson, Granbery. “New Federal Structure is Beautiful and Commodious”. Greensboro Daily News (Greensboro, North Carolina), May 28, 1933, p. B 7. ↩︎
“Three Developments Center About New Federal Building”. Greensboro Daily News (Greensboro, North Carolina), July 4, 1933, p. 5. ↩︎
“Greensboro Is Ready For Dedication of New Federal Building Today”. Greensboro Daily News (Greensboro, North Carolina), July 6, 1933, p. 1. ↩︎
P. Thornton Marye. Highlands Methodist Church (1909). Birmingham, Alabama.
Highlands Methodist Church is the central landmark of Birmingham, Alabama’s Five Points district, and is a fine example of the Spanish Renaissance Revival style.P. Thornton Marye of Atlanta designed the structure, which was completed in 1909.1
Location of Highlands Methodist Church
Apparently, “oral history” says thatStanford White of McKim, Mead & White was originally tapped to design the church and Marye took over after White’s death,2 which is pure fabrication.
I’ve read variations of the “Stanford White actually designed this” tale connected with buildings in Anniston, Alabama; Chattanooga, Tennessee; and Macon, Georgia. All of them are bullshit.
White never designed any structures in the Deep South—the furthest south he ventured for work was the University of Virginia.
In the case of Highlands Methodist, it’s well-documented that Marye was awarded the contract for the church’s design in April 1909,34 two months before White’s death. Research, people.
Southerners are liars to the core, but you have to wonder why so many apparently wanted to be associated with a well-known pedophile and rapist like White, especially Christians.
Actually, now that I write that out, it makes perfect sense.
Bem Price with P. Thornton Marye. Bell tower on Highlands Methodist Church (1921). Birmingham, Alabama.567
Originally named Five Points Methodist,8the church was Marye’s second major project in Birmingham.
At the same time, he oversaw the design and construction of the city’sTerminal Station, and the two structures were completed within a month of each other.910
However, the church has more in common with Marye’s design for the Gulf, Mobile, and Ohio Railroad Passenger Station in Mobile, Alabama, completed in 1907. Both buildings share the same style, and the church design reuses multiple elements from the station.
I consider Marye one of Atlanta’s more underrated architects, and he deserves praise for his work on Highlands Methodist.
With its oversized Palladian windows, elaborate terracotta ornamentation, cream-colored brick, and deep-red Spanish tiles, the church’s appearance teeters on the gaudy, but Marye’s bold massing and skillful proportion mercifully restrain the composition.
In less talented hands, it could have been horrific.
As Marye designed it, the church was originally much more open to the surrounding neighborhood, with four main entrances—two on the west and two on the south.11
Later additions and large fences compromised that openness, and today Highlands UMC conceals all but its west facade, making it appear more like an aloof old neighbor who shuns the street.
It’s still striking and attractive, though.
Gallery
Palladian window on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaTerracotta keystone, finials, and bell gable on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaParapet and finial on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaBell gable, circular window, terracotta keystone and ornamentation on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaParapet, finial, and niche on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaCircular window, arch window, and finials on the south facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaBell tower on Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaCircular window, terracotta ornamentation, and broken pediment on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaBell tower window, volute, and finial on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaFinial, parapet, second-floor window, and niche on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaTerracotta ornamentation on the bell tower of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaTerracotta brackets and brick corbels on the bell tower of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaWindows on the tower of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaWindows and brick corbels on the tower of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaCupola with Spanish tile roof on Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaCircular window, keystones, and terracotta ornamentation on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaFinial on the cupola of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaTerracotta finial and egg-and-dart trim on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaGable, finial, cupola, and Spanish tile roof on Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaTerracotta ornamentation and dentilled cornices on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaNorth gable, tower, and Spanish tile roof on Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaSpanish tile and cornice on the tower of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaDentilled cornice, terracotta ornamentation, keystone, and capitals on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaBroken pediment on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaWindows and consoles on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaSolomonic columns on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaVolute and finial on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaEntrance to Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaWindows and Solomonic columns on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaWindows and consoles on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaTerracotta consoles on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaWindows on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaPalladian window on the south facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaColumn bases and consoles on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, AlabamaLooking at the Palladian window on the facade of Highlands Methodist Church, Birmingham, Alabama
P. Thornton Marye with Frank K. Thomson. Auditorium (1911-1930). Raleigh, North Carolina. Illustration from a postcard published by James E. Thiem of Raleigh and postmarked on March 13, 1922.
The postcards here depict the Auditoriumand Municipal Building in Raleigh, North Carolina, completed in October 1911123 and April 1912,4 respectively, and designed by P. Thornton Marye of Atlanta.56
Frank K. Thomson78 of Raleigh’s Barrett & Thomson served as associate architect91011 and supervised construction.12
The two connecting structures were “erected as one”13 and constituted the first of six major projects Marye designed for Raleigh, all built between 1909 and 1915. Only one of those projects—the State Administration Building14—survives.
Location of the Municipal Building and Auditorium
The postcard at the top shows the Auditorium‘s facade and east elevation, flanked by the Municipal Building’s south elevation. Despite its title (“The Auditorium”), the postcard below depicts the Municipal Building, with only part of the Auditorium visible.
The two-story buildings were faced with cream-colored brick1516and Indiana limestone,1718 and topped with a tile roof.19 A 1911 article claimed the project was designed “in part on a Colonial scheme,”20 though that was plainly inaccurate. Maybe the writer meant Spanish Colonial, given the tile roof. It’s a stretch, though.
An earlier report correctly described the style as “of the French Renaissance school”21—a.k.a. Beaux-Arts. I fully agree with that assessment, based on the buildings’ formal symmetry, dentilled cornices, and terracottaornamentation,2223 including shields, festoons, and decorative keystones.
The Municipal Building housed the mayor’s office, city court and council chambers, police station, and other departments,2425 while the Auditorium, designed in “amphi-theater form,”26 could host events for 4,50027 to 5,000 people.2829
The Auditorium’s interior incorporated inclined ramps instead of steps,3031 which was apparently a novel feature, and Marye reportedly custom-designed all the building’s furniture.32
Although he may have been closely involved in its design, I wouldn’t consider this one of Marye’s better works—based on these photographs, anyway.
D.H. Burnham & Company. Washington Union Station (1907). Washington, D.C.
Marye was a Virginia native33 who practiced for 10 years in Virginia and D.C.,34 and he designed three major train stations in the Southeast, so he was surely familiar with Washington’s.
In the Union Station design, Burnham’s team topped the facade’s three giant arches with an absurdly high parapet to achieve visual balance. Up close, the design looks clumsy, but from a distance, it appears grand and imposing—quite fitting for a city of monuments.
The Auditorium may have looked better from a distance, too, but these postcards suggest its parapet neither balanced the composition nor complemented the large arched bays.
Marye clearly intended a bold, audacious design, but the low, flat roofline suppressed the arches, and in these images, both structures appear flat, boxy, and oddly languid.
He also wrapped both buildings in an oversized cornice, a device Haralson Bleckley of Atlanta often used. It visually connected the two structures, but failed as a focal point: the eye still wanders to the blank mass above the cornice.
It would have been much more dynamic if Marye had kept the cornice and eliminated the parapet entirely, letting the arches form the roofline, as he did to fantastic effect with the Gulf, Mobile and Ohio Railroad Passenger Station in Mobile, Alabama, and Highlands Methodist Church in Birmingham, Alabama.
P. Thornton Marye. Municipal Building (1912-1961). Raleigh, North Carolina. Photograph from an undated postcard by The Albertype Co. of Brooklyn, New York.
As it was, the roof design was clearly problematic: less than three years after its opening, the Auditorium was already experiencing leaks that “caused a steady downpour of rain in certain sections of the immense assembly hall.”35 The building’s wooden entrance doors were also reportedly rotting.36
Local roofers opined that “an entirely new roof should be placed on the building,”37 but of course they would say that.
Marye was summoned by city officials to address the building’s problems,3839 and he assured the mayor that he would “take up the matter of the repairs that are needed on the structure and that everything necessary would be attended to.”40
What that meant for the roof is unclear, but Marye’s solution for the front doors was to cover them in metal.4142 You have to wonder why they weren’t metal in the first place.
It had been just over a decade since the infamous Iroquois Theatre fire in Chicago, which killed over 600 people, and fire safety was still a hot topic when it came to the construction of public buildings—especially theaters.
As Marye was attending to the Auditorium’s repairs in 1914, one article noted rather presciently:
“…it is to be remembered that no fire escapes have ever been placed on this building, though, of course, this had nothing to do with Mr. Marye’s part of the work, and he is not expected to see to the placing of these further additions for the safety of persons who might be occupying the building at the time of an emergency.”43
The “time of emergency” came 16 years later, when a fire destroyed the Auditorium on October 25, 1930.
The 18-year-old facility was hosting the Negro State Fair Marshall’s Ball that evening when a blaze broke out between 11:45 and midnight. Investigators suspected the fire began in “one of the men’s dressing rooms where smoking was going on.” 44 Seems logical.
Nearly 1,000 people were present at the event, but everyone escaped without injury, and the adjoining Municipal Building was spared as firemen used “every available piece of fire equipment in the city.”45 By the time the fire was extinguished at 1 a.m.,46 only the front wall remained standing.47
The day after the fire, the News and Observer remarked:
“Raleigh didn’t know how much of a fire trap it had in its midst until the city auditorium burned down. The roof crashed in within 20 minutes after the fire was discovered. Think what might have happened, if the auditorium had been crowded with people.”48
The city quickly built a replacement venue a few blocks south—that facility, the Raleigh Memorial Auditorium, still stands.
The former Auditorium site was eventually replaced with a gas station,49 which was later converted to an annex for the municipal building, by that time known as City Hall.5051
With the opening of a new city hall, demolition of the Municipal Building began in November 196052 and ended in January 1961, making way for—bet you’ll never guess—a parking lot.5354
References
“Municipal Building And The Auditorium”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), October 15, 1911, p. 25. ↩︎
“Dedication Exercises At Raleigh Auditorium”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), October 17, 1911, p. 7. ↩︎
“Acclaim Of Thousands Greets The Auditorium”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), October 18, 1911, p. 7. ↩︎
‘City “At Home” In New Building’. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), April 18, 1912, p. 5. ↩︎
“Will Cost $90,000”. The Evening News (Raleigh, North Carolina), July 17, 1909, p. 1. ↩︎
“A Place Of Pride For All Raleigh”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), July 18, 1909, p. 1. ↩︎
“Raleigh’s $125,000 New City Building”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), January 27, 1910, p. 1. ↩︎
“Municipal Building And The Auditorium”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), October 15, 1911, p. 25. ↩︎
“Will Cost $90,000”. The Evening News (Raleigh, North Carolina), July 17, 1909, p. 1. ↩︎
“A Place Of Pride For All Raleigh”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), July 18, 1909, p. 1. ↩︎
“Municipal Building And The Auditorium”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), October 15, 1911, p. 25. ↩︎
“Will Cost $90,000”. The Evening News (Raleigh, North Carolina), July 17, 1909, p. 1. ↩︎
“Municipal Building And The Auditorium”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), October 15, 1911, p. 25. ↩︎
“The New State Administration Building”. The Raleigh Daily Times (Raleigh, North Carolina), June 10, 1911, p. 1. ↩︎
“Raleigh’s $125,000 New City Building”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), January 27, 1910, p. 1. ↩︎
“Raleigh’s Progress In Million Dollar Figures”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), September 14, 1910, p. 2. ↩︎
“Municipal Building Work.” The Evening Times (Raleigh, North Carolina), August 23, 1910, p. 8. ↩︎
“Raleigh’s Progress In Million Dollar Figures”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), September 14, 1910, p. 2. ↩︎
“Municipal Building And The Auditorium”. The News and Observer (Raleigh, North Carolina), October 15, 1911, p. 25. ↩︎
Willis F. Denny. Jefferson County Courthouse (1904). Louisville, Georgia.123Clock tower on the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaAcroterion, eaves, brackets, dentilled cornices, and terracotta cartouche on the facade of the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaPediment, terracotta ornamentation, and Scamozzi capitals on the facade of the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaEaves, cornice, quoins, terracotta cartouche, and Scamozzi capitals on the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaEast facade of the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaCircular window and eaves on the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaLooking up at the south elevation of the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaSecond-floor window and pediment over a side entrance of the Jefferson County Courthouse, Louisville, GeorgiaWillis F. Denny. Jefferson County Courthouse with 301 E. Broad Street Residence (attributed) in background.