A.C. Bruce (1835-1927) was a founding partner of Bruce & Morgan, the most prolific architectural firm in Atlanta and the Southeast in the late 19th century.
The following article was written by Bruce in 1896 for the Southern Trade Review, a short-lived business journal that was published in Nashville between 1896 and 1897.1 2 The article was then reproduced in the Nashville Banner and is now reproduced here.
In the article, Bruce provides a brief history of the antebellum architects of Nashville, where he grew up and trained in the profession before establishing a solo practice in Knoxville, Tennessee,3 later moving to Atlanta in 1879.4
Although the article mentions several local Nashville architects, Bruce had particularly high praise—and justly so—for William Strickland, a Philadelphia architect who designed the Greek Revival-style Tennessee State Capitol (1859) and the Egyptian Revival-style First Presbyterian Church (1851), both of which survive and are among the better buildings in a city that is fairly lacking in quality architecture.
Bruce was 61 years old when he wrote this article, and apparently relied entirely on memory, so there are some understandable errors to note:
The article also mentions P.J. Williamson‘s design for the Deaf and Dumb Asylum in Knoxville, Tennessee, without noting that Bruce himself designed an 1873 addition for the building,8 which still survives.
Of Early Days And Something About Them.
The First Professional Architect Was Col. Adolphus Heinan—William Strickland, Who Planned the State Capitol—Other Men of Note.
(A.C. Bruce, in Southern Trade Review.)
After reading the very interesting letter of W.C. Smith, architect on the subject of “Architecture in the South,” I thought possibly that your paper, as a technical journal, would like to know something about Nashville’s older architects, who directed the building operations in the 40’s and early 50’s. Although of a local nature, it may be interesting to some of your readers and bring to their minds some of the incidents long since passed.
Being reared in the building business by my father, who was for many years a well-known contractor, and for thirty-five years a resident of Nashville, my early impressions of architecture were directed to its studies by coming in contact with the leading, I believe, the only architects, professionally as such, at that time. I will mention first Mr. James Hughes, who no doubt is still remembered by many of the older citizens. The old bank buildings, many of which have been either torn away or remodelled [sic], were planned and built by him. He could be seen daily on the corner of Union and Cherry streets—and the Public Square and College street—with a neat roll of paper under his arm, possibly some newly made drawing. Among his first work was the Second Presbyterian Church on North College street, ministered to at that time by Rev. Dr. Lapsley. A few years later he built the present Catholic Church on the corner of Cedar and Summer streets, which up to this time is a fine study of church architecture, with a very effective treatment in Italian style, which fully characterized all his important work. About the same time he built the old Commercial Hotel, on the corner of Cedar and Cherry streets.
One of the masterpieces of his church work was the magnificent church built by the Christian Church during the pastorate of the Rev. Jesse B. Ferguson, on Cherry street, between Cumberland alley and Church street. It was burned to the ground in a few years after building. Many of his elegant country residences are yet standing in Davidson, Maury and Giles Counties, beautiful examples of the Southern palatial homes found in nearly every important city in the South, so truly spoken of in Mr. Smith’s paper when he said: “The most of the buildings, therefore, were, up to within a few years of that period, designed by builders, and were to a great extent modelled after the old Colonial work, indicating a more refined taste and a more thorough knowledge of the principles of design than is to be found in much later work.”
Many of the older citizens remember the old McNairy residence, which stood on the corner of Cherry and Church streets, once used for the postoffice, those large, fluted columns, the dentilled entablature, heavy projecting cornices. It was one of the finest and best buildings of that day. In the march of progress it had to give way for the new present occupied by the The Nashville American Printing Company. For many years Mr. Hughes directed the architecture of the city as the leading architect and builder. He died in Nashville sometimes in the 50’s.
Contemporary with Mr. Hughes there came from New Orleans the first professional architect to locate in Nashville, Col. Adolphus Heiman (afterward Gen. Heiman, killed in the civil war in Mississippi), whose skilled hand designed many of the public educational structures about Nashville, and many of its residences. A fine piece of his work can be seen in the old collegiate Gothic building on the University grounds, South Nashville. I think he also built the Atheneum at Columbia and the old Shelby residence now in the limits of East Nashville, but at that time a far-off country residence. He also planned the jail built in the ’50’s, the first insane asylum near Nashville and was the architect and engineer for the first suspension bridge. I have been told that Col. Heiman was the architect of the State capitol of Louisiana, at any rate it bears a strong resemblance to his work about Nashville. Many private residences were also designed by him. He was a graduate of a Prussian school of engineering and architecture. Col. Hughes graduated from the work bench after years of architectural study and practical application, each masters of the profession in their day.
Nashville was growing in wealth and population, a new State capitol was to be erected, finer buildings were being proposed, and the capitol commission called William Strickland, a prominent architect from Philadelphia, to build the capitol. He came and his monument stands yet on Capitol Hill, one of the finest proportioned architectural structures in the United States, the pride of every Tennessean. Many other noted structures built by him are yet standing, principally the First Presbyterian Church, corner of Summer and Church streets, designed in the Egyptian style of architecture with its peculiar details carried out both in its exterior and interior treatment. None but a master hand in architecture would have suggested such a radical change in church architecture as he made in the Presbyterian Church design. The massive Kirkman residence on the corner of Summer and Cedar streets was one of his most artistic designs, elaborately worked out in every detail regardless of cost.
I remember when a boy going in the building with one of the workmen to look at the elaborate ornamental plaster work, which I think was done by men imported for that work and to carry out his special designs. After a few years work in Nashville he, too, passed away and was buried in a catacomb prepared in the erection of the capitol for his body. I remember well attending the funeral services of this distinguished architect this month forty-two years ago.
Shortly after the death of Mr. Hughes and Mr. Strickland there came to Nashville an old English stair-builder, Mr. Samuel Moore, with his son Joseph, who, being expert workmen in the building lines, soon found work with a leading contractor in that day, Mr. Jesse Warren, who did so much in the building up of Nashville. The young man, Joe, as he was familiarly called, soon took the lead in directing the architectural work, and shortly became a partner under the firm name of Warren & Moore. Business increased, still greater demand for architectural services were required by the wealthy citizens, and the above firm sent to New York and engaged the services of Mr. H.M. Akeroid [sic], a professional architect of ability and experience. Soon his chaste and ornate designs were seen on many important streets, elaborate carvings, massive columns and arches altogether different in style from his predecessors above mentioned. His work showing an educated style peculiar to the English school, from which he had just graduated, and throughout his architectural career in Nashville he kept up with the advanced ideas of his clientage, producing the best architectural effects in all his studies. (Allow me to say here that under Mr. H.M. Akeroid [sic] I received much valuable instruction and gratuitous teaching, which impressed me with the study of architecture in addition to my practical training to follow architecture as a profession, and I am satisfied that whatever success I have had in the twenty-five years of practice was, in a measure, due to the advice of him whom I am ever pleased to remember most pleasantly.) After a few years, Mr. Akeroid [sic] returned to New York, and, I think, died there.
During the stay of Mr. Akeroid [sic] in Nashville the demand for wood carving was greatly increased, and a young, artistic workman, gifted with the pencil and skilled in the execution of elaborate designs of carving, was found in the person of W.K. Dobson. His training had been along the lines of architectural carving; we soon seen [sic] in him an architect of exquisite design and practical training, which fitted him for the successful work and extensive practice he enjoyed in Nashville for a number of years. I can only mention a few of the finer pieces of his work. The St. Cecilia Academy, in North Nashville, many of the older school buildings and of Nashville’s handsomest storehouses erected in the later 50’s were the result of his handiwork.
Many of the citizens will remember Nashville’s first Exposition, held in the year 1880, erected on the corner of Broad and Vine streets, where the custom-house and postoffice now stand, from design by Mr. Dobson. Many other important structures throughout the city are yet standing to attest his skill and ability. Several years before the war, Mr. P.J. Williamson came to Nashville, and, being experienced in the profession, soon entered upon a large and extensive practice, erecting many of the handsomest and most costly buildings during that period, principally the Deaf and Dumb Asylum at Knoxville, Tenn., the Blind Asylum at Nashville and a number of the recent church edifices throughout the city. Soon after his arrival a partnership was entered into with himself and Mr. Dobson under the firm name of Dobson & Williamson, and continued for a number of years. Mr. Dobson moved to Texas, and Mr. Williamson has, I think, retired from active practice, making way for the younger men who now hold the architectural business of the city in its present metropolitan advancement. It is not my purpose to speak of them, as that will be left to some one in the twentieth century to write of them as I have attempted to do of those in this letter.10
The YWCA in downtown Birmingham, Alabama, has occupied the former Birmingham Athletic Club (1925)1 since 1948.2
This fine vintage sign, sans its original neon, hangs on the building’s southwest corner (3rd Avenue North and 23rd Street North) and appears to date from that time.
