Category: A. Ten Eyck Brown

  • W.S. Loftis Residence (1926) – Atlanta

    A. Ten Eyck Brown. W.S. Loftis Residence. Druid Hills, Atlanta.
    A. Ten Eyck Brown. W.S. Loftis Residence (1926). Druid Hills, Atlanta.1

    References

    1. “Handsome North Side Apartment House”. The Atlanta Constitution, March 7, 1926, p. 2C. ↩︎
  • United States Post Office (1933) – Atlanta

    A. Ten Eyck Brown with A. Barili, Jr., and J.W. Humphreys, associate architects. United States Post Office (1933). Atlanta.
    A. Ten Eyck Brown with A. Barili, Jr., and J.W. Humphreys, associate architects. United States Post Office (1933). Atlanta.1

    Don’t let Atlanta historians fool you: A. Ten Eyck Brown (1878-1940) likely had little to do with the design of this monumental structure, which ranks among the city’s most exquisite buildings.

    Opened in December 19332 as the United States Post Office, the project appears to have been primarily designed by Brown’s associate architects, Alfredo Barili, Jr., and J. Wharton Humphreys, who established their own firm a few years later.3

    Compare the later works credited to Brown with those of his early years, and it’s clear that his own skills were inadequate for the more sophisticated designs that emerged from his firm in the 1920s onwards—this project is no exception.

    East facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    East facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta

    Designed in the Classical Moderne style, the building sits atop a base of Stone Mountain granite and is sleekly clad in Georgia marble.4

    The structure’s otherwise smooth facades on the east and west are punctuated by a trio of slightly recessed bays that recall Brown’s earlier design for the Fulton County Courthouse, but the effect is much more successful here.

    Indeed, the courthouse design is a joyless mess: the building’s facade is cluttered with windows of varying sizes, and the deeply recessed center bay, supported by six multi-story columns, resembles a giant jail grating.

    In this design, the variation in the bays is much subtler, and the windows are given space to breathe, providing enough contrast and visual balance for a pleasing, cohesive composition.

    This building also shines in its incorporation of fine textural detail, trimmed with pilasters, friezes, and stringcourses in stark geometric patterns, many of which are of pre-Columbian inspiration. Emphasizing the structure’s bold ziggurat form, the design evokes the image of some ancient American temple dropped into a modern metropolis.

    Ornamentation on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Ornamentation on the United States Post Office, Atlanta

    The project was completed for the princely sum of $3 million,5 and the volume of materials used in its construction is staggering: the structure is composed of 12,222 marble pieces totaling 4,798,404 pounds, with the largest block weighing 8,400 pounds.6

    Atlanta, of course, never pays for quality architecture, and this bulwark of a building exists only because it was bankrolled by the United States government.

    At the time, federal building projects were supervised by the U.S. Treasury, and Brown was a natural choice to pick as the lead architect, since he began his career in the office of the supervising architect of the Treasury.7 8

    Brown was approaching the end of his life and career in the 1930s and was well-respected in Atlanta and the Southeast. Known as “Tony” to his friends,9 he became one of the city’s wealthiest architects in the early 20th century, with his firm designing dozens of large-scale public buildings across multiple states, though his fortunes appear to have been greatly reduced during the Depression.

    Preston Stevens of Stevens & Wilkinson described him as “debonair and attractive,” and recalled a claim by another architect, Francis P. Smith, who said that ‘”Tony” could almost hypnotize his clients by sitting across the table from them and sketching designs upside down.’10

    Bay on the southwest corner of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bay on the southwest corner of the United States Post Office, Atlanta

    I can’t criticize Brown too much for claiming primary credit on this project, as most architects of the era did the same. The myth of the lone designer had long become untenable, and by the turn of the 20th century, every Atlanta architect managed a team of design assistants.

    As building projects grew increasingly large, costly, and complex to manage, most prominent architects effectively became figureheads, promoting their businesses and securing commissions while delegating the actual design work to their employees.

    It’s well documented that numerous projects credited to Atlanta architects of the time, like W.T. Downing, Morgan & Dillon, W.A. Edwards, and Hentz, Reid & Adler—to name a few—were designed by assistants, many of whom went on to establish their own firms.

    Brown at least had the decency to share credit with the actual designers of his projects—often listing them as associate architects or supervising architects—a practice he began in 1922, when he was appointed the supervising architect for more than twenty public school buildings in Atlanta,11 12 nearly all of which were designed by other architects.13 14

    Contrast his approach with, say, G. Lloyd Preacher, who claimed credit for every work produced by his firm, even though it was abundantly clear which projects weren’t his own. The most striking example is Atlanta’s fine neo-Gothic city hall, credited to Preacher but designed by one of his employees, George H. Bond,15 who was infinitely more talented.

    Looking at the United States Post Office, Atlanta, from the southwest
    Looking at the United States Post Office, Atlanta, from the southwest

    Questions of credit aside, the former United States Post Office (later renamed the Martin Luther King, Jr. Federal Building) is one of the few structures in the city with any actual design caliber, and its quality of craftsmanship and attention to detail are unknown to modern architecture, in Atlanta or elsewhere.

    Gallery

    Looking at the United States Post Office, Atlanta, from the northeast
    Looking at the United States Post Office, Atlanta, from the northeast
    Bas-relief string course and windows on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief stringcourse and windows on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    First-floor window and bas-relief string course on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    First-floor window and bas-relief string course on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Windows on the south elevation of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Windows on the south elevation of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Center bay on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Center bay on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief ornamentation and first-floor window on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief ornamentation and first-floor window on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Main entrance of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Main entrance of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Nickel-alloy transom panels and sconce at the entrance of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Nickel-alloy transom panels and sconce at the entrance of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Nickel-alloy sconce at the entrance of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Nickel-alloy sconce at the entrance of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Marble block on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Marble block on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Inscription and windows on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Inscription and windows on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    A pair of windows on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    A pair of windows on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Cornice on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Cornice on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief stringcourse, ornamentation over a first-floor window on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief stringcourse, ornamentation over a first-floor window on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief stringcourse and dentilled cornice on the south elevation of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief stringcourse and dentilled cornice on the south elevation of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief ornamentation on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Bas-relief ornamentation on the facade of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Windows on the south elevation of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Windows on the south elevation of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Granite base, pedestal, and steps on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Granite base, pedestal, and steps on the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Cornerstone of the United States Post Office, Atlanta
    Cornerstone of the United States Post Office, Atlanta

    References

    1. National Register of Historic Places Continuation Sheet: United States Post Office, Federal Annex ↩︎
    2. Hamilton, Tom J., Jr. “Leaders Laud Administration Policies at Dedication of Atlanta’s New $3,000,000 Post Office Building”. The Atlanta Journal, December 3, 1933, p. 1. ↩︎
    3. “Barili & Humphries Architectural Firm Is Announced Here”. The Atlanta Journal, February 21, 1937, p. 6-D. ↩︎
    4. “New Post Office Is Dedicated And Accepted By City”. The Atlanta Journal, February 19, 1933, p. 1-B. ↩︎
    5. Hamilton, Tom J., Jr. “Leaders Laud Administration Policies at Dedication of Atlanta’s New $3,000,000 Post Office Building”. The Atlanta Journal, December 3, 1933, p. 1. ↩︎
    6. ibid. ↩︎
    7. “New P.O. Building Praised”. The Atlanta Constitution, March 27, 1931, p. 7. ↩︎
    8. “Noted Architect Succumbs Here At Age of 62”. The Atlanta Constitution, June 9, 1940, p. 1. ↩︎
    9. Stevens, Preston. Building a Firm: The Story of Stevens & Wilkinson Architects, Engineers, Planners Inc. Atlanta (1979), p. 67. ↩︎
    10. ibid. ↩︎
    11. “A. Ten Eyck Brown Made Supervising School Architect”. The Atlanta Constitution, January 21, 1922, p. 1. ↩︎
    12. “May Start Building Of 30 New Schools In Near Future”. The Atlanta Journal, January 22, 1922, p. 1. ↩︎
    13. “School Building Program Adopted By Board Friday”. The Atlanta Constitution, March 25, 1922, p. 1. ↩︎
    14. “Architect To Split School Plan Work”. The Atlanta Journal, March 25, 1922, p. 9. ↩︎
    15. Stevens, Preston. Building a Firm: The Story of Stevens & Wilkinson Architects, Engineers, Planners Inc. Atlanta (1979), p. 70. ↩︎
  • Fulton County Courthouse (1914) – Atlanta

    A. Ten Eyck Brown and Morgan & Dillon, associate architects. Fulton County Courthouse (1914). Atlanta. 
    A. Ten Eyck Brown and Morgan & Dillon, associate architects. Fulton County Courthouse (1914). Atlanta.1 2
    Looking at the south elevation of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Looking at the south elevation of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Looking up at the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Looking up at the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Scamozzi capitals and cornice on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Scamozzi capitals and cornice on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Crest, dentilled cornice, and ninth-floor windows on the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Crest, dentilled cornice, and ninth-floor windows on the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    A bay of windows on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    A bay of windows on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Columns, pedestals, and second- and third-floor windows on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Columns, pedestals, and second- and third-floor windows on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Second- and third-floor windows on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Second- and third-floor windows on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Soffit and Corinthian pilaster capital on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Soffit and Corinthian pilaster capital on the facade of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Entrance of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Entrance of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Pediment, keystone, and transom window over a door on the front entrance of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Pediment, keystone, and transom window over a door on the front entrance of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Light and pedestal at the entrance of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta
    Light and pedestal at the entrance of the Fulton County Courthouse, Atlanta

    References

    1. “Plans Completed For Courthouse”. The Atlanta Constitution, April 6, 1911, p. 1. ↩︎
    2. “Fulton County’s Million Dollar Courthouse”. The Atlanta Constitution, May 12, 1914, p. 1. ↩︎
  • “This Georgia Woman Stands High In Her Profession” (1902)

    Henrietta C. Dozier (attributed). G.W. Gignilliat Residence. Seneca, South Carolina.
    Henrietta C. Dozier (attributed). G.W. Gignilliat Residence. Seneca, South Carolina.1

    The Background

    Henrietta Cuttino Dozier (1872-1947), professionally known as Henrietta C. Dozier, was the first female architect in the Southeastern United States, practicing in Atlanta from 1901 to 1914, and then in Jacksonville, Florida, for the remainder of her life.

    The United States had 22 female architects by 1895,2 increasing to more than 200 by 1920.3

    Starting in the 1890s, the slow but steady rise of women in male-dominated professions, including architecture, spurred a flurry of press articles, with claims of a “woman invasion” stoking fierce public reaction—keep in mind, women weren’t even allowed to vote until 1920.

    Atlantans’ first exposure to a “lady architect” came during the development of the Cotton States and International Exposition in 1894, when plans for the Women’s Building were solicited exclusively from female designers—a radical idea at the time.

    Upon seeing the submitted plans, Thomas H. Morgan of Bruce & Morgan reportedly remarked with surprise: “Why, these buildings are bold enough to have been drawn by men.”4

    When the competing plans were later exhibited in New York, Charles McKim of McKim, Mead & White was equally incredulous: “Of course the young ladies did the drawing, and it is very well executed, but whose idea was the design? Their teacher’s, I suppose?”5

    Elise Mercur of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, secured the commission for the Women’s Building, winning over 12 other submissions, including one by Dozier, who was then studying at the Pratt Institute in New York.6 7 Dozier entered Pratt as its only female student, ranking second in her class.8

    Dozier (pictured here9) was born in Fernandina Beach, Florida, but raised in Atlanta by her single mother—her father died four months before she was born.10

    She attended the Atlanta public schools before heading north, where she studied at Pratt and later the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), graduating in 1899 with a B.S. in Architecture11—one of just three women in a class of 176 students.12

    An unconventional woman for her era, Dozier never married, reportedly dressed in men’s clothing, and was known to her friends and family as “Harry” and “Uncle Harry”13 14 15—draw your own conclusions.

    In 1893, The Atlanta Journal described “Harry Dozier” as “a young girl of unusual force and mental determination. She is quite young, and quite handsome…”16

    Dozier learned to fly airplanes in her 60s,17 and following her death, her relatives were surprised to discover a manuscript she had written for an unpublished romance novella. Sample text:

    “Men do not get what they deserve in life, they get what they go after,” said Elizabeth. “So? My dear, I think women do a lot of going after what they want also … At least, you know how to get what you want.”18

    Only one of Dozier’s known works survives in Atlanta: a residence she designed for Mrs. O.K. Slifer on 10th Avenue overlooking Piedmont Park. The structure now serves as a school building and has been altered.

    Henrietta C. Dozier. O.K. Slifer Residence (1912, altered). Atlanta.
    Henrietta C. Dozier. O.K. Slifer Residence (1912, altered). Atlanta.19 20

    Although Dozier often downplayed her professional difficulties in interviews, there is ample evidence that she faced severe discrimination in a field that largely remains an old boys’ club.

    As one article noted in 1903: “It is only recently that the men in the profession began to regard women architects as other than a huge joke.”21

    Dozier wasn’t a spectacular designer by any means, but she also wasn’t given nearly as many opportunities to refine her skills as her male counterparts, securing few large-scale commissions throughout her career.

    In a 1939 interview, she noted: “…in the last few years, I have done nothing but small residential homes.”

    Dozier added that she was “always very proud” of her work on the Jacksonville branch of the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta,22 which can easily be considered her finest effort.

    She was officially credited as supervising architect for the project, working under A. Ten Eyck Brown of Atlanta. However, Brown often claimed credit for projects he had little to no hand in designing, and it appears Dozier did most of the work.

    A. Ten Eyck Brown with Henrietta C. Dozier. Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, Jacksonville Branch (1924), Jacksonville, Florida. Photograph from an undated postcard.
    A. Ten Eyck Brown with Henrietta C. Dozier. Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, Jacksonville Branch (1924), Jacksonville, Florida.23 Photograph from an undated postcard.

    In 1905, Dozier was elected an Associate of the American Institute of Architects (AIA), only the third woman to be accepted into the organization.24 Dozier’s election directly led to the establishment of the Atlanta chapter of the AIA,25 which later became AIA Georgia.

    As T.H. Morgan recounted, a minimum of five AIA associates were required to form an AIA chapter, and Dozier, along with Harry Leslie Walker, became the fifth and sixth architects in the city elected as associates, prompting the chapter’s organization.26

    During her life, Dozier’s work was barely acknowledged by the local press—in either Atlanta or Jacksonville. The handful of news stories written about her often conveyed a tone of curious skepticism, if not outright ridicule.

    The following article, published in The Atlanta Constitution in 1902, is the first of just a few that were written about Dozier during her time in Atlanta, and it’s about as sexist and condescending as it gets.

    Dozier had been in practice less than two years, and the reporter (obviously male) depicted her interest in architecture as some girlish lark before settling into marriage, claiming that she:

    “…makes plans for a future fair with promise, where she may realize a woman’s dreams of ease and mental and domestic pleasure, surrounded by the friends she loves—nature and children and dumb things.”

    Maybe that’s what Dozier told the reporter to keep him happy, but she clearly had other ideas for herself.


    This Georgia Woman Stands High in Profession of Architecture

    Of all the branches of work into which women are entering there is none which shows so small a percentage of the really successful as that of architecture, and this is particularly true in the south. Two reasons deter the young woman casting about for something upon which to settle. In the first place, it is hard work; in the second, there is the probability of marriage—the state few on the sunny side of twenty-five or thirty could be brought to regard as anything but the ultima thule to which woman existence tends. And when one there is who from choice enters seriously upon a real profession the world might as well see at once, what sooner or later it will have to see, that she will succeed.

    When Miss Henrietta C. Dozier entered as apprentice in an architect’s office she set herself to work as a man does—not simply to bridge over a year or two until the time when she would marry—she began at the beginning and held on to the finish. A year of apprenticeship was followed by two at Pratt Institute; then after some months in New York she went to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, remaining four years. Coming south, she opened an office in Jacksonville, Fla., where she was in business six months, but in compliance with solicitations from friends in Atlanta decided to remove to this place, where she is permanently located and established, doing business with a man’s understanding and knowledge and a woman’s thoroughness and regard for detail.

    Architecture is peculiarly suited to woman from the fact that her ideas on the requirements of a house are more practical than those of a man. Too, if she has first an all-round knowledge of mechanics her artistic instinct will serve her well. Miss Dozier, realizing what a woman wants and knowing how to go about having it, has built her own house—a unique and picturesque cottage, modern and complete, and meeting her needs as nobody else could have planned for her.

    Here, in her hours of recreation, she enjoys with her mother and sister the sweetness of home, and makes plans for a future fair with promise, where she may realize a woman’s dreams of ease and mental and domestic pleasure, surrounded by the friends she loves—nature and children and dumb things.

    Miss Dozier, like Dorothy Manners, has “the generations” back of her. Her forbear, Thomas Smith, of South Carolina, was landgrave in 1663, or there abouts, and a long line of ancestors have bequeathed to this young woman the intrepid spirit which no mere circumstance can daunt, and placed in her slender hand the key which unlocks every door—a will that brooks no thwarting.

    As an architect she is a success; she has mastered her profession and she makes it pay.27

    References

    1. Wells, John E. and Dalton, Robert E. The South Carolina Architects, 1885-1935: A Biographical Dictionary. Richmond, Virginia: New South Architectural Press (1992), p. 42. ↩︎
    2. “Uncle Sam And The New Woman.” St. Louis Post-Dispatch, June 30, 1895, p. 32. ↩︎
    3. Allaback, Sarah. The First Women Architects. Urbana, Illinois: University of Illinois Press (2008), p. 2. ↩︎
    4. “Current Events From A Woman’s Point Of View.” The Atlanta Constitution, December 2, 1894, p. 6. ↩︎
    5. “Their Plans Are Complete.” The Atlanta Journal, November 26, 1894, p. 6. ↩︎
    6. “Plans By Fair Hands”. The Atlanta Constitution, November 28, 1894, p. 5. ↩︎
    7. “Tiffany Will Be Here.” The Atlanta Journal, November 28, 1894, p. 6. ↩︎
    8. “Society”. The Atlanta Journal, March 18, 1893, p. 2. ↩︎
    9. Photo credit: Wood, Wayne W. Jacksonville’s Architectural Heritage: Landmarks for the Future. Jacksonville, Florida: University of North Florida Press (1989), p. 9. ↩︎
    10. Spotlight: Henrietta Dozier – Jacksonville History Center ↩︎
    11. ibid. ↩︎
    12. “Atlanta Girl Is Lionized.” The Atlanta Constitution, June 8, 1899, p. ↩︎
    13. “Society”. The Atlanta Journal, March 18, 1893, p. 2. ↩︎
    14. Parks, Cynthia. “‘Cousin Harry’ Practiced What She Built”. The Florida Times-Union (Jacksonville, Florida), July 18, 1976, p. G-2. ↩︎
    15. Weightman, Sharon. “They called her Harry”. The Florida Times-Union (Jacksonville, Florida), July 10, 1994. p. D-4. ↩︎
    16. “Society”. The Atlanta Journal, March 18, 1893, p. 2. ↩︎
    17. ↩︎
    18. Weightman, Sharon. “They called her Harry”. The Florida Times-Union (Jacksonville, Florida), July 10, 1994. p. D-4. ↩︎
    19. “The Real Estate Field”. The Atlanta Journal, October 31, 1911, p. 19. ↩︎
    20. “Some Personal Mention”. The Atlanta Journal, January 28, 1912, p. L5. ↩︎
    21. Chapman, Josephine Wright. “Do Women Architects Underchage?” The Atlanta Journal, November 14, 1903, p. 15. ↩︎
    22. Spotlight: Henrietta Dozier – Jacksonville History Center ↩︎
    23. “New Federal Reserve Bank Home”. The Sunday Times-Union (Jacksonville, Florida), June 1, 1924, p. 19. ↩︎
    24. Weightman, Sharon. “They called her Harry”. The Florida Times-Union (Jacksonville, Florida), July 10, 1994. p. D-4. ↩︎
    25. Morgan, Thomas H. “The Georgia Chapter of The American Institute of Architects”. The Atlanta Historical Bulletin, Volume 7, No. 28 (September 1943): pp. 89-90. ↩︎
    26. ibid. ↩︎
    27. “This Georgia Woman Stands High In Profession of Architecture”. The Atlanta Constitution, October 12, 1902, p. 6. ↩︎

  • First National Bank (1913) – Dublin, Georgia

    A. Ten Eyck Brown. First National Bank (1913). Dublin, Georgia.
    A. Ten Eyck Brown. First National Bank (1913). Dublin, Georgia.1 2 3 4

    References

    1. “Sealed Proposals for the Erection and Completion of Bank and Office Building for the First National Bank, Dublin, Georgia”. The Atlanta Constitution, April 21, 1912, p. 4. ↩︎
    2. “Atlanta Firm Will Build Dublin Bank”. The Atlanta Constitution, June 3, 1912, p. 2. ↩︎
    3. “Dublin National Bank Declares Dividend”. The Macon News (Macon, Georgia), January 27, 1913, p. 2. ↩︎
    4. “Dublin Is Erecting Eight-Story Building”. The Atlanta Journal, January 27, 1913, p. 2. ↩︎